Song of the Post: Holidays, by Miami Horror
Introspection can be quite important. I've been thinking about myself a lot lately; not in any particularly more conceited way than usual, but in a more practical sense of self. Namely, the disconnect between how I perceive myself and how others perceive me. I remember something from an article I once read, about how frightening the thought of ones "self" is. It is a common refrain to say that someone "doesn't know the real you", which implies that there is somehow another person inside you that you only reveal in bits and pieces, over time. The article in question, if I recall, argued that this was ridiculous. That every interaction you have with others is, in fact, the real you. That not opening up at first is an aspect of your personality which does allow the person you are interacting with to know you.
This is not a totally unreasonable argument, but it does, I think, approach the true meaning of self in a slightly obtuse way. We have, sometimes, an unfortunate habit of making decisions and taking actions in a somewhat chaotic, or counterproductive way. Our thoughts do not always match our words or our actions, which natively creates a bias between what we think of ourselves and how others perceive us. We do, in fact, have another person inside us from the one we display. It is as ridiculous and frightening as it sounds, but it is the truth.
Last week, one of my good friends was kind enough to let me read over his shoulder during seminar, and I spotted a line that I very much like. In Walter Isaacson's biography of Da Vinci, he says, "Vision without execution is hallucination." This on the surface might seem to support the argument that we are only what others perceive us to be, but I would not be so quick to discount hallucinations. Hallucinations have form in their own right, and can be quite powerful. How you perceive yourself can absolutely dominate your understanding of how others perceive you, and in turn create a reality for yourself to inhabit. I would argue that this might be true for most people, most of the time, myself included, so that a large part of our lives is spent interacting with a world we consider to be different from what others consider it to be.
Consider two personal anecdotes. I will provide my interpretation with the understanding that my perception may be completely detached from reality.
First, I have loved Star Wars for many years. Star Wars, especially the Expanded Universe of Star Wars, has been a significant factor in both my personal and public perception. Most, if not all, of my friends have some understanding that I am a fan of Star Wars. However, I would say, was a fan of Star Wars. Star Wars as most everyone else interacts with it is about as far from how I interact with it. I have been unable to overcome my feelings of betrayal when it comes to the new canon and its abandonment of the EU. I have no interest in seeing or reading any of the material realeased or published post Disney. Not because I am concerned with quality, it's possible they are all very well executed movies and novels, but because it is not the Star Wars I care about. My ambivalence is... difficult for some of my friends. While I perceive I have been nothing but consistent, it seems that some of them simply cannot truly comprehend that I have no desire to engage with anything new that is Star Wars related. In this case, it is my interpretation that other's perceptions of me are incorrect; that they are living in a world that is separate from reality.
There are certainly no shortage of situations of the converse; where I have a warped perception of reality and the people around me know me better than I know myself. It is certainly difficult to admit to specific situations, since they shed light on aspects of our personality we'd like to keep hidden. The one that springs most readily to mind might seem simple, but had a profound effect on me. I don't remember the exact context, but in class one day about four years ago I said something along the lines of "I don't think anyone works quite as hard as I do."
I swear, in my mind, it didn't sound that bad. I could swear, my intention, was to illustrate how dumb I was; that I had to work so hard because nothing came as easily to me as it did everyone else. And already, I'm embarassed for myself because both of those justifications are bullshit. It's all a self aggrandizing of my plight; poor, poor me. One of my friends immediately said, in what was probably a half-joking way, "Well, that's a pretty arrogant thing to say." I opened my mouth to explain my reasoning, how it wasn't, but he was absolutely right. It was arrogant, and I was arrogant for saying it. Of course my perception of how hard I work was inflated, because I have to spend the most time with me, and I had perceived that I was working an unreasonable amount. But by discounting the reality that others were working just as hard, some certainly harder, I showed a lack of empathy and an arrogance that I was rightly called out for. I still do this, from time to time. I have, however, been actively working to improve this aspect of my personality, and my perception is that I have been making some gains.
Maybe my friends can correct me if I'm wrong.
What this all comes to, I'm afraid, is that there can be no way to truly know our selves. We only have two sometimes quite unreliable sources; our own perception and our understanding of other's perception. We look in the mirror and see a different person than everyone else sees, we hear ourselves speak and hear a different voice. There is a person inside of us, hiding from the light, who we alternatively guard and coaxe out. There is the person everyone sees, that everyone knows likes Star Wars and is a little full of themselves, and there is the person who doesn't like Star Wars and is being modest, but only lives inside their own perception. Can they both be real? When I look in the mirror what do I see? Vision without execution is, after all, only hallucination.
Song hint: You can rely on the old man's money.